Removal of tags from disabled scenes

[bab85]

Follow-up to the thread Amélioration des tags :

@pierre-gilles

@Terdious

I think a tag that ends up with 0 uses should be automatically deleted, no?

that’s the case, there’s no such thing as a tag with zero usage

Good evening everyone,
Following up on the quotes above, I noticed that a tag that is only assigned to scenes that are disabled is deleted.
Is this intentional or accidental?
As I’m still in the learning and testing phase, I have equipment that is used in several scenes, so I regularly enable or disable scenes. But if a tag is no longer present on an active scene, it is deleted. I understand that in steady operation this problem probably doesn’t arise, so if it’s intentional, I’ll live with it (we didn’t have access to the tag until recently ), but if this happens like that without any further reason, I’d submit a feature request .

[Psoy]

hello @bab85
Yes, this bug has already been reported, it’s being discussed here:

Gladys Assistant 4.31 : Filtre par tag & MQTT dans les scènes

pour les dev quelques remarques [image] Il faudrait un petit texte pour préciser qu’il faut taper le nom du tag dans la zone « Select » ou remplacer « Select » par quelque chose comme « Entrez le nom du tag ici » car pas évident à trouver la première fois Un petit bug j’ai mes scènes [image] j’actives les tags [image] je coche le filtrage se fait bien [image] je décoche mais les scènes ne réapparaissent pas [image] il faut cliquer sur plans puis à nouveau sur Scènes p…

But I thought it was fixed with version 4.32

[bab85]

Hello @Psoy
Indeed I hadn’t noticed that it had already been mentioned (in fact, in the discussion thread, I hadn’t understood that the tag had been removed).
However, I’m on v4.33 and I can confirm that this behavior is still present.

[pierre-gilles]

@bab85

Following the quotes above, I noticed that a tag that is only assigned to scenes that are disabled gets removed.
Is this intentional or accidental?

Yes, it’s intentional A tag only exists in a scene, so if no scene has that tag, it doesn’t exist

[bab85]

My best wishes to everyone for this new year.
@pierre-gilles my disappearing tags are indeed associated with scenes, but those scenes are disabled.

[Terdious]

Yes indeed, same for me today… that’s not the intended behavior. We’ll see!

[pierre-gilles]

Ok, in that case I’d like someone to create a GitHub issue to keep a record of the bug

[Terdious]

It’s done:

Tag on scene feature: When all scenes of a tag are only disabled, the tag is deleted

[Terdious]

Hi @pierre-gilles,

I replied to you, you obviously forgot that the topic has already been raised twice. I had, however, included the reference to that discussion in the issue:

Tag on scene feature: When all scenes of a tag are only disabled, the tag is deleted

[pierre-gilles]

Ah sorry, I read a bit too quickly, it’s indeed a bug in that case

[Terdious]

Have a great vacation, get some good rest!!

[pierre-gilles]

I looked at this bug, it’s really trivial!

It’s fixed here:

Fix #2000 : Should not delete tags when patching scene without tags