Is it possible for you to send a photo of how these sensors look? I get the impression that they’re really big compared to the Xiaomi.
In private if you prefer ![]()
I have both, and it’s true that Sonoff devices are a bit bigger than Aqara ones.
Hello
There you are reasoning like a technician, and when you apply that you end up with these ambiguities. It’s more user-friendly to say that the sensor is open to mean the window is open. What I mean is that when I create a scene, I think « when my window is open I send a message » and not " when my sensor is closed (which means my window is open) I send a message" I hope I’m clear🤔
Hello
You didn’t reverse anything at all, you had already done it before, it caused an uproar because we had to change our scenes, and after a debate of the same kind as this one, we therefore returned to the current state ![]()
That’s why I say we should show what makes sense to the user.
Window/door open or closed — 0 or 1 doesn’t matter
We just need to be logical on the tech side and on the user side.
So we’re agreed about the user😉, what matters is that the trigger fires on opening and not on closing
I just reread my previous message and indeed I’m completely wrong: it’s not
If I’m not mistaken, the newer Aqara models are smaller, but I don’t have the dimensions to give you right now.
Ok perfect, we’ll just swap the translations then
The 0 and 1 won’t change so as not to affect the scenes already created, just the text on the UI side!
Thanks for the feedback!


