Control of roller shutters

I would see this kind of design for example:

(icons taken at random, but that’s the idea)

This is exactly what is generally used and it’s the most effective.

At your choice in the middle a STOP button icon or a PAUSE type icon, each to their own!

In the long run (long term?), the ultimate goal is to be able to configure « fixed » points in the shutter position to easily find them again.

For example, at my place in the evening I don’t fully close one of my shutters so that my cats can pass: the simplest solution is to have a dedicated button with a percentage value.

The very poorly illustrated version of what you proposed @pierre-gilles is:

Living room shutters DOWN | STOP | UP | 25% | 85%

Why not in the long term, but I think just having simple control for now is already a big step forward :slight_smile: Let’s keep the basic functionality simple but working well, we’ll see later for special cases.

3 commands for a feature.
How do you think we should handle the command messages? 0(up), 1(stop), 2(down)?
Will the « up » and « down » buttons, after being pressed, remain activated (highlighted, for example) until the stop feedback is received?

0 - UP
1 - STOP
2 - DOWN
yes certainly

And not stupid the story of the highlighting for devices that handle feedback.

As said @pierre-gilles let’s start simple.
If someone takes the subject, let him signal, otherwise I will do it during koh-lanta :stuck_out_tongue:

Something like this?

Line 1: Actions
Line 2: Position

EDIT: It doesn’t work for curtains :confused: it’s better to use the « OPEN/CLOSE » concept

I really like it!

However, I think it would make more sense if it’s the same curtain that there is no « separation » between the two lines. Otherwise, it seems like they are two different devices.

These are 2 different features. For now, on the dashboard, we display one line per feature.

@AlexTrovato Are there devices that handle these 2 types of controls? Isn’t it one or the other?

You usually have both

For your information, here’s what my switches from Aliexpress allow:

For my device roller shutters ( CCT5015-0001 ) I have:

  • position (as above)
  • lift_duration

I have several Tuya-compatible models at home, from different « generations »:

  • 1st generation: « Open », « Close » and « Pause »
  • 3rd generation: « Open », « Close » and « Stop », plus « Trip time » (or « Calibration time » — up/down movement time) and « Backlight » (with scheduler)

On ALi, the latest generation also allows adjusting the opening percentage (screenshot by @guim31)…

@AlexTrovato Do you have the code for this UI somewhere?

After the Alexa development, I’m tempted to start this development :slight_smile:

The idea would really be to release a minimal version that works well for the most common case (open/close/pause)

I think it’s on this branch

https://github.com/atrovato/Gladys/tree/roller-shutter

It’s already been developed, actually :smiley: Nothing to do—or almost!

I love reading this!!

Here’s what my dashboard looks like right now (using Node-RED) to manage the roller shutters:

That’s a huge brick for just 2 roller shutters! (and on top of that the position slider doesn’t work)

I can’t wait until I can group the up/down/stop actions :+1:

We had talked with @VonOx about this, and we thought of showing « open / close » rather than up/down chevrons, since the shutter or curtain might open from left to right.

Hello guim31
What equipment do you use to control your pool cover that must be low-voltage?
Thanks for your reply
GV

Hi @lsage :slightly_smiling_face:

Actually there’s a misnomer: it’s the roller shutter (of a sliding glass door) that faces the pool! However, I still control my pool’s underwater light, the pump, and the 12V terrace spotlights with a 4-way Zigbee switch