New YouTube video coming out tonight: Home Assistant vs Gladys Assistant: The Honest Comparison 2026 (Which one to choose?)
In my opinion, itâs a video thatâs going to do really well. I noticed that this keyword is highly searched, so it will fill a gap and answer questions from users who are hesitating between the two solutions.
In this video, I compare the two solutions across 6 criteria (installation, compatibility, automations, communityâŠ) with no sugarcoating: I say what HA does better AND what Gladys does better.
A little favor? If you have 30 seconds, a comment under the video (even a quick comment) would greatly help the YouTube algorithm get it discovered by more people
However, I notice a gap between theory and practice: Iâm regularly told that YAML is not mandatory in Home Assistant, but in fact, virtually all video tutorials, blog posts and forum discussions refer to it
Itâs understandable: bloggers generally try to offer advanced configurations, but in my opinion that can intimidate beginners who are discovering the platform
Do you think I can share this video on HACF or will it be poorly received?
I would avoid it.
But itâs a very good video.
It looks like youâll hit the mark with the dual setup!
I donât know if you can make changes to an already published video.
I put myself in the shoes of an English person, so I enabled automatic translation. There were a few small mistakes, like « Gladys » translated as "Gladi
Iâm putting my comment here because Iâm not a fan of YouTube & co. (the less I write on it, the better I feel).
The video is very good, itâs very clear, no « dissing » of the opposing solution but a highlighting of each oneâs pros and cons, great! (and it also helped me understand the philosophy of Home Assistant (HA) a little better )
Regarding the stats, it worked well in 24 hours, especially with almost 50 comments â itâs really a great success. I donât know if you can find out where the visitors came from but I think that would be really interesting.
And Iâll finish with the last slide about a dual install which is brilliant
Iâm saying this because thatâs what I do and Iâm even on 3 installs (Gladys, Home Assistant (HA) and my old Jeedom) , everything communicates over MQTT. And I even went as far as adding Homey SHS to the mix to share and test Z2M (Zigbee2MQTT) and Matter for a month (after that, Homey requires payment)!
In short, MQTT and Matter make a great duo for sharing device values.
Thatâs a very good idea!
I would envision a neutral video presenting a home automation assistant, to spark interest and show that itâs simple to make your apartment or house smart from a hardware point of view.
At the end of the video, there should be only a single pre-made dashboard showing only the products you demonstrated in the video, with Gladys of course, to show the ease of use (on/off, simple automation)
In this video, I wouldnât yet show pairing devices or setting up scenes or commands on the dashboard (thatâs more what the training will cover) but just explain that you did it in 5/10/15min.
Great work @pierre-gilles â I hope it brings you people.
Also, in my home automation journey I first went through HA; I was really taken by the fact that, without me asking, it suggested integrations for network devices (printer, etcâŠ)⊠but in the end I dropped the tool because I understood NOTHING about YAML, and because the more I tried to move forward, the more I broke things.
Hence my interest in Gladys, which, on the other hand, doesnât break anything as you go!
When reading a comment on the video, I thought maybe you should give people the option to try Gladys+ for a month before having to pay, so new users can get a full idea of what Gladys can do.